knest.ai • Property intelligence for home buyers
How to Negotiate a House Price in Australia
The agent sitting across the table from you isn’t neutral. They’re paid by the seller to get the seller the best price, and that single fact should shape how you play the whole negotiation. This isn’t a scandal. It’s the rule of the game, and knowing it is your biggest advantage.
Negotiating a house price is less about nerve than about knowing who’s on whose side and what the evidence says. The agent is working for the seller, the asking price is a starting point rather than a verdict, and the rules on what an agent can claim are tighter than most buyers assume. Line those up first and the number looks after itself.
Here’s the buyer-side plan: set your number from evidence, open it well, read what the agent can and can’t say, and negotiate on more than the dollar figure. If you’re earlier in the process, start with the basics of making an offer on a house, then come back here for the price itself.
- The asking price is a starting point, not the property’s value. Base your number on comparable sales, then set a ceiling.
- Open below your true ceiling so you have room to move, and put every offer in writing.
- The agent works for the seller. Consumer Affairs Victoria confirms their responsibility is to the vendor, though they must still deal with you honestly.
- An agent can say other offers exist but can’t invent them. Underquoting is illegal in states such as New South Wales and Victoria.
- Nothing is binding until contracts are exchanged or signed, so once you agree, move quickly.
How do you work out what to offer?

Start from evidence, not the asking price. Consumer Affairs Victoria describes a private sale as the agent working toward “a mutually acceptable price and terms”. That tells you the listed figure is a negotiating start point, not a verdict on value. Work out a fair number from recent sales first, then decide your ceiling.
The method for actually valuing a property lives in its own guide, so we won’t repeat it here. If you want the full approach, start with what comparable sales say it’s worth and the wider walkthrough on how to work out what it’s worth. Those do the heavy lifting on value.
One thing is worth saying plainly: the price guide isn’t the value. A guide is an advertised figure, and our explainer on why the price guide isn’t the value shows how far the two can drift apart. So before you talk to anyone, lock in two numbers. The number the evidence supports, and the absolute ceiling you won’t cross for this property.
How do you make your opening offer and handle the counters?
Offering below the listed price is a normal opening move. Consumer Affairs Victoria tells buyers to “offer a lower price and be prepared to negotiate upwards,” so opening below your ceiling is expected, not cheeky. Put the offer in writing, set a date it lapses, and let the agent carry it to the seller.
Here’s a simple order to work through:
- Decide your ceiling. Fix the highest number the evidence supports before emotion gets involved.
- Open below it. Leave yourself genuine room to move upward without blowing past your limit.
- Put it in writing. Consumer Affairs Victoria recommends writing in a date by which your offer lapses, which sets how long it stays open.
- Expect a counter. A counter-offer is the normal next step, not a rejection of you.
- Move in small increments. Small, slow steps signal you’re near your limit. One big jump signals you have more to give.
- Know your walk-away. Decide the point where you stop, and mean it.
A few habits hold this together. Keep your true maximum to yourself, because the moment the agent knows it, that number becomes the target. You might also be asked for a “best and final” offer. That’s a process where the agent invites each interested buyer to submit a single strongest offer by a deadline (Consumer Protection WA). Treat it as your genuine ceiling, not a round to be gamed. One caution: a plain written or emailed offer isn’t binding on its own, but the document you sign to make an offer can be the contract itself. In Queensland you make the offer by signing the contract (Queensland Government), and in WA an online offer is “generally a signed Offer and Acceptance contract, which carries legal obligations if accepted” (Consumer Protection WA). So before you sign any offer form or contract, have your conveyancer confirm when it becomes binding where you’re buying.
Who does the real estate agent actually work for?
The agent acts for the seller. Consumer Affairs Victoria states that although an agent’s responsibility is to the seller, they must also act responsibly and ethically when dealing with you, the buyer. So treat them as the vendor’s representative, stay courteous, and keep your leverage firmly to yourself.
That duty actually cuts in your favour in one way. The agent must communicate genuine offers to the seller (Consumer Affairs Victoria). In New South Wales, they must pass on all offers to the vendor right up until contracts are exchanged, unless the vendor has given written instructions otherwise, such as not to submit offers below a set price (NSW Government); if yours won’t be passed on, the agent must tell you. So a written offer usually reaches the seller, even a low one, which is one reason to put it in writing.
What you don’t want to hand over is your position. How much you want the place, how high you’d really go, how far you could really stretch: all of that is leverage, and it’s yours to keep. Being friendly with the agent is fine. Confiding your ceiling to them is not, because their job is to get the seller your best possible number.
Can the agent lie about other offers?
An agent can tell you other offers exist, but they can’t invent them. Consumer Protection WA says agents must act honestly, not mislead or deceive you, and must take reasonable steps that any offers are genuine. Underquoting the price is illegal in states such as New South Wales and Victoria, so there are real limits on what an agent may claim.
The rules actually allow more than you’d think. In some states an agent may tell you there are competing offers and invite your best offer, and the seller then decides whether to accept, reject or negotiate (Consumer Protection WA). That’s permitted. What isn’t permitted is making up a buyer who doesn’t exist, or advertising a price below what the agent genuinely expects the property to sell for.
That second one is underquoting. In New South Wales, an agent must not advertise or state a price below their reasonable estimate of the likely selling price (NSW Government). Where a price range is advertised, the top can’t exceed the bottom by more than 10 per cent, so a range starting at $500,000 can’t top $550,000 (NSW Government). Victoria applies the same 10 per cent cap to an advertised range, and underquoting there also covers advertising below the agent’s estimate, the seller’s asking price, or a price the seller has already rejected (Consumer Affairs Victoria). That range cap is the agent’s advertising limit, by the way, not a hint about how far below to offer.
So what do you do when you hear “there’s another offer on the table”? Lean on your own evidence and your ceiling, not the pressure in the room. If a competing-offer claim is genuinely moving your number, you can ask for it in writing, though the agent isn’t obliged to provide it (NSW Government). A claim you can’t see in writing shouldn’t be the thing that lifts your bid.
Price isn’t the only lever you can pull

When you can’t move further on price, you can still move the deal. Consumer Affairs Victoria notes you can negotiate to make a sale subject to certain conditions, which means settlement timing, deposit size and flexibility are all on the table. The right term can win a seller over without raising your number at all. What a given vendor values varies, though, so it’s worth asking the agent what matters to them before you trade anything away.
| Lever | Why it can appeal to the seller | The buyer-side catch |
|---|---|---|
| Settlement timing | A longer or shorter settlement can suit the seller’s own move or cash-flow timing. | A settlement that doesn’t match your finance or living plans can cost more than it saves. |
| Deposit size | A larger deposit can signal you’re committed and able to complete. | A larger deposit ties up more cash early and reduces your flexibility if something changes. |
| Conditions | A cleaner offer with fewer conditions looks simpler and more certain to the seller. | Dropping a finance or inspection condition trades away your safety net, not just paperwork. |
| A flexible, prompt offer | Clear terms and a ready buyer lower the seller’s risk of the deal falling over. | Moving fast can’t mean skipping checks you’d later regret. |
One line matters more than the rest in that table. Don’t drop your finance or inspection condition just to win on price. Your deposit refund and your ability to walk away usually hinge on that condition and on meeting its notice and timing (Consumer Protection WA); drop the condition and that protection goes with it. Our guide to conditional vs unconditional offers sets out exactly what you’d be giving up.
What happens once your price is accepted
A “yes” on price isn’t the finish line. Nothing is binding until contracts are exchanged in New South Wales (NSW Government) or signed in Queensland (Queensland Government). The gap between acceptance and exchange is where a deal can still fall over. Once you’ve agreed a number, your job is to move to exchange promptly.
That gap has a name on the buyer’s side: gazumping, where a seller accepts a higher offer before the sale is binding. The risk lives in that window, so moving quickly to a signed, binding contract is your best defence. Having your finance, deposit and conveyancer lined up early turns a verbal “yes” into a signed deal faster.
Much of this gets easier when you’ve done the groundwork before you ever name a price. The questions to ask first covers what to confirm about the property, the contract and the seller’s situation, so your number and your terms rest on facts rather than guesses.
Negotiation can feel personal, but the buyer-side version is mostly discipline. Evidence sets your number. The agent works for the seller, and the law limits what they can claim: no invented buyers, no underquoting in states such as New South Wales and Victoria. Price is one lever among several, so use settlement, deposit and terms before you overpay, and keep your finance and inspection conditions intact. The one line that doesn’t change: base your number on evidence, and don’t hand over your position.
A property report brings the risk and comparable context behind your number into one place: flood, bushfire, zoning, power lines, noise and nearby sales. Your offer then rests on what you can see rather than what you’re told.
View a sample reportFrequently asked questions
How much below the asking price should you offer?
There’s no fixed percentage. Offering below the listed price is normal in a private-treaty sale, and Consumer Affairs Victoria suggests you offer lower and be prepared to negotiate upwards. The right gap depends on what comparable sales show and the state of the market, not a rule of thumb. Open below your ceiling and move from there.
Can a real estate agent lie about other offers?
They can tell you offers exist, but they can’t invent them. Consumer Protection WA says agents must act honestly and take reasonable steps that any offers are genuine, and underquoting is illegal in states such as New South Wales and Victoria. If a claim is moving your number, you can ask for it in writing, though the agent isn’t obliged to provide it (NSW Government).
What is a “best and final” offer?
It’s a process where the agent invites each interested buyer to submit a single strongest offer by a deadline, with no further rounds (Consumer Protection WA). Treat it as your genuine ceiling, not a bluff to beat. A plain written offer isn’t binding on its own, but in some states the document you sign to make the offer is the contract itself: in Queensland you make the offer by signing it (Queensland Government), and in WA a signed Offer and Acceptance carries legal obligations if accepted (Consumer Protection WA). Have your conveyancer confirm when it binds before you sign.
Does the agent have to tell the seller my offer?
In New South Wales, the agent must pass on all offers to the vendor right up until contracts are exchanged, unless the vendor has given written instructions otherwise, such as not to submit offers below a set price (NSW Government); if yours won’t be passed on, the agent must tell you. More broadly, Consumer Affairs Victoria says buyers can expect an agent to communicate genuine offers to the seller.
Can you negotiate the price down after a building inspection?
You can use findings from a pre-purchase inspection to ask for a lower price, but the seller doesn’t have to agree. Whether you can actually walk away depends on your inspection condition and on meeting its notice and timing, which is why keeping that condition in your offer matters (Consumer Protection WA). Drop it to win on price and you give up that leverage.
Sources
- Consumer Affairs Victoria, “Seek expert advice on property”, retrieved 2026-10-27, https://www.consumer.vic.gov.au/housing/buying-and-selling-property/buying-property/seek-expert-advice-on-property
- Consumer Affairs Victoria, “Buying property by private sale”, retrieved 2026-10-27, https://www.consumer.vic.gov.au/housing/buying-and-selling-property/buying-property/buying-property-by-private-sale
- Consumer Affairs Victoria, “Property sales method and price”, retrieved 2026-10-30, https://www.consumer.vic.gov.au/housing/buying-and-selling-property/selling-property/property-sales-method-and-price
- Consumer Protection WA, “Make your property offer online: what you need to know”, retrieved 2026-10-27, https://consumerprotection.wa.gov.au/announcements/the-commissioner-asked-make-your-property-offer-online-heres-what-you-need-know
- NSW Government (NSW Fair Trading), “Underquoting guidance”, retrieved 2026-10-27, https://www.nsw.gov.au/housing-and-construction/property-professionals/working-as-an-agent/underquoting-guidance
- NSW Government, “Making an offer on a property”, retrieved 2026-10-27, https://www.nsw.gov.au/housing-and-construction/buying-and-selling-property/buying-property-nsw/making-an-offer-on-a-property
- NSW Government, “Contracts and deposits when buying property in NSW”, retrieved 2026-10-27, https://www.nsw.gov.au/housing-and-construction/buying-and-selling-property/buying-property-nsw/contracts-and-deposits
- Queensland Government, “Contract of sale”, retrieved 2026-10-27, https://www.qld.gov.au/law/housing-and-neighbours/buying-and-selling-a-property/buying-a-home/making-an-offer-on-a-home/contract-of-sale
Daniel Ryan, Editor, Buyer Guides & Property, knest.ai
General information only. This article is general information for Australian home buyers. It isn’t personal legal, financial, credit or tax advice, and it isn’t a property valuation. Underquoting rules, agent conduct obligations and how a sale becomes binding are set by state and territory legislation and by the wording of your contract, and they change. Check the current position where you’re buying, and verify your own contract and your options with a conveyancer or solicitor licensed there. knest.ai is an AI property-intelligence platform that supports buyer judgment; it isn’t a conveyancer, solicitor, broker or building inspector, and it doesn’t replace them.
Recommended for you
Questions to Ask Before You Make an Offer
Conditional vs Unconditional Offer, Explained
What "Subject to Finance" Means in Australia
How to Make an Offer on a House in Australia
How to Research a Property Before Buying in NSW: The 12 Checks
Do You Need a Conveyancer to Buy a House? (And Can You DIY?)